The Prophetic and the Limitation of Authority in Modernist Islam
The “prophetic”, as a central concept in modernist Islamic political philosophy, has been invoked to show that Islamic political philosophy takes into account the spiritual as well as the material world. However, this expansion of the prophetic had remained relatively silent as to the authority that is granted to experiencing individuals. This essay is a story of these reinterpretations the “prophetic” by three major Muslim thinkers – Muhammad Iqbal (d. 1938), Ali Shari‘ati (d. 1977), and Abdolkarim Soroush (b. 1945). Writing in different periods and trying to respond to different questions, these authors engaged with the question of politics by reference to prophetic experience. Fatima Tofighi explains their intellectual context, according to their cosmologies and their notions of language (participation vs. representation). She analyzes how in different intellectual context, the force of a democratic notion of the prophetic was undermined by different reinterpretations.
